- Brotherton, Mark R.
Mark was the first Bucknell soccer player to be named all-conference four straight years. A four-year letterman and two-time co-captain, he was named to the All-East Coast Conference Team after each of his four seasons with the Orange and Blue
- Domsohn, David P.
Dave Domsohn was one of the most dominant players to set foot on the soccer pitch at Bucknell. A four-year letterman and co-captain in his senior season, Domsohn led the Bison in scoring in each of his four years and set school career records for goals (52), assists (34) and points (138).
- Gibbons, Elisabeth
- Ott, R. Lyman
Twice captain of the soccer team, Lyman Ott set season and career scoring records and was named to the All-MAC Northern Division, All-Tri State and All-American teams.
- Rath, David P.
Dave Rath was one of the finest soccer players ever at Bucknell and held the school career goals record (42) for 20 years.
- Strasburg, Bruce E.
A four-year letterman in soccer and captain of the 1974 Bucknell team, Bruce Strasburg was selected to the All-Middle Atlantic Conference team in 1973 and 1974 and was Most Valuable Player of the Western Section of the MAC in 1973.
- Strasburg, Scott A.
An All-America second team selection in 1976 and a four-year letterman in soccer, Scott Strasburg helped lead Bucknell to a 39-11-4 record, an East Coast Conference championship in 1974 and three straight appearances in the NCAA Tournament.
- Toubman, Gary B.
Gary Toubman became the seventh Bucknell soccer player to earn Hall of Fame distinction when he was enshrined in 2004.
