How to Write a Strong Counselor Recommendation Letter

Writing a counselor recommendation letter for a student applying to college is a meaningful responsibility. You're not just offering support — you're adding valuable context that college admissions officers rely on to see the full story behind the student's application. But what exactly should you include? How do you structure it? And how can you ensure your letter makes an impact?

Here's a practical guide for school counselors looking to write powerful, authentic recommendation letters that stand out.

Why These Letters Matter More Than You Think

Recommendation letters have some serious clout in the admissions process. Some colleges consider them more important than class rank, extracurricular activities and, at least when it comes to the counselor recommendation, demonstrated interest.

According to the 2023 NACAC "Factors in the Admission Decision" survey, 11.9% of colleges rated counselor recommendation letters as having "considerable importance" and 40% rated them as having "moderate importance." 

That means your letter could make the difference in a competitive review.

What Should a Counselor Recommendation Letter Include?

College admissions officers want to understand who a student is beyond test scores and GPAs. Your letter should provide:

• Context about your school: Unique features or circumstances we may not catch on the school profile.
• Insight into the student's character: Integrity, resilience, empathy, leadership and how they've grown.
• Your professional perspective: How does this student compare to others you've worked with? What makes them exceptional?

Keep your tone warm and professional. Avoid simply repeating the student's resume. Instead, tell a story that shows the "why" behind their achievements.

How Do I Write a Strong Letter of Recommendation for a Student?

In her insightful article "What Every Counselor Recommendation Should Include," college admissions expert Sarah Harberson emphasizes that counselor recommendations should be rooted in specific character traits, personal anecdotes, and honest insights—not résumé summaries.

The best letters don't attempt to list every accomplishment or rely on long strings of generic adjectives. Instead, they:

• Focus on 3–5 defining traits or values
• Provide concrete examples or short stories that illustrate those traits in action
• Contextualize school-specific achievements (e.g., a highly selective course)
• Keep the letter concise—ideally one page

Letters like these give admissions readers what they truly need: a clear, authentic picture of the student from someone who knows them well.

Why Specifics Matter

Admissions officers read thousands of recommendation letters. The most memorable ones don't list every accolade—they highlight a few key traits and bring them to life with short, specific stories. If you can illustrate a student's character in action, your letter will stand out and provide the context colleges are looking for.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Relying on generic, cliché language without examples
• Omitting important school context
• Repeating the student's resume
• Skipping proofreading

Tools That Can Help

While you focus on writing a thoughtful letter, a few tools can help streamline the process and provide inspiration:

• Word Cloud Generators: Use these to visually brainstorm a student's standout traits — a helpful warm-up if you're experiencing writer's block.
• Slate.org: View students' application statuses, upload and manage recommendation letters, and communicate with admissions offices.
• Counselor Toolkits: Access free templates, writing prompts, and professional tips specifically designed to help counselors write stronger letters.

These tools won't write the letter for you, but they can simplify and enrich the process so you can focus on what matters most: the student's story.

Final Thoughts: Write With Heart and Honesty

A great counselor recommendation letter reads like a story that only you can tell. You have the unique vantage point of seeing your students grow, struggle and shine in ways others might not. Lean into that perspective.

Because when it comes down to it, the strongest letters don't just check a box. They offer a window into a student's potential to thrive, contribute and lead.

Looking for more resources? Tell us what resources will support you best.